SCNTMIX may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Prices were checked on September 29, 2026 and change often.
Short answer: Armaf Club de Nuit Untold lists the same notes as Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 (saffron and jasmine, amberwood and ambergris, fir resin and cedar) and scores a 93% match in SCNTMIX. Untold costs $33.95 for 3.6 oz; Baccarat Rouge 540 costs $445.89 for 2.4 oz. Buy Untold if you want the style for everyday wear; buy Baccarat Rouge 540 if you want the original and its reputation.
The price gap, per ounce
- Club de Nuit Untold: $33.95 for 3.6 oz at FragranceShop, about $9.40 per ounce.
- Baccarat Rouge 540: $445.89 for 2.4 oz at FragranceNet, about $186 per ounce.
That is roughly twenty times more per ounce for the original. For the price of one 2.4 oz Baccarat Rouge 540, you could buy a bottle of Untold every month for a year and still have money left over.
The two bottles
Armaf Club de Nuit Untold 93% match
Notes: saffron, jasmine; amberwood, ambergris; fir resin, cedar.
Wear: above-average longevity, strong projection.
Best for: daily wear, trying the style, spraying freely.
Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 The original
Notes: jasmine, saffron; amberwood, ambergris; fir resin, cedar.
Wear: 10 to 14 hours, heavy projection.
Best for: collectors, gifts, anyone who wants the name on the bottle.
What's the same
On paper, almost everything. Both open on saffron and jasmine, sit on an airy amberwood and ambergris heart, and dry down to fir resin and cedar. That is the sweet, glowing, slightly mineral trail people recognize across a room, and it is why Untold is our highest-rated match for Baccarat Rouge 540.
What we can't promise
Matching note lists do not guarantee an identical bottle. The sources behind our 93% match describe Untold as a close reproduction, but none measure exactly how its balance, texture or development differ from the original. Baccarat Rouge 540 also has a decade of reputation that no clone can copy. If the compliment "is that Baccarat?" matters to you, that is the original's real advantage.
Who should buy which
- Buy Club de Nuit Untold if you love the Baccarat style, want to wear it every day without rationing sprays, or want to test the style before a big purchase.
- Buy Baccarat Rouge 540 if you are buying a gift, collecting the originals, or already know you want the real thing.
- Try both first if you are unsure. A sample of each costs a fraction of either bottle, and wearing them on separate days is the fairest test.
Make it last longer
Both are built on long-lasting base notes. Spray moisturized skin and clothing, and see what actually helps a fragrance last longer. Want to change the mood? Run either bottle through MixMode to see what layers well with it.
More options: every Baccarat Rouge 540 alternative we've reviewed, including Al Haramain Amber Oud Rouge Edition (92% match).
Frequently asked questions
Is Club de Nuit Untold the same as Baccarat Rouge 540?
No, but it is close. It lists the same notes and scores a 93% match in SCNTMIX. The sources behind that match describe it as a close reproduction, not an identical formula.
How much cheaper is Club de Nuit Untold?
On September 29, 2026, Untold cost $33.95 for 3.6 oz and Baccarat Rouge 540 cost $445.89 for 2.4 oz, roughly $9.40 versus $186 per ounce.
Does Club de Nuit Untold last as long as Baccarat Rouge 540?
Untold is rated above-average for longevity with strong projection; Baccarat Rouge 540 is rated 10 to 14 hours with heavy projection. Both sit on long-lasting amberwood, fir resin and cedar.
Should I sample before buying?
Yes, especially for Baccarat Rouge 540. Try a sample of each on separate days before committing to a full bottle.